City Cast Las Vegas logo

The Secret to Perfect Pumpkin Pie

Posted on November 26, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Sarah Lohman

Sarah Lohman

A pumpkin grows on the vine

The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin. (Sarah Lohman/City Cast Las Vegas)

If you want to make a really fab pumpkin pie — and have space for a container garden — grow Long Island Cheese Pumpkins! Although this eating squash has an East Coast name, it’s believed to be one of the oldest domesticated squashes and originally hailed from South America. Mojave desert gardeners have noticed that this pumpkin thrives in our hot, arid summers.

It’s famously a low water, high sugar, less-stringy squash that’s perfect for pumpkin pie. All you need is a deep container and seeds from Mojave-based seed sellers Mantis Planting. Make sure to water the roots deeply, but then just let the vines wander and bring a splash of green to your yard 🌱 It takes about 100 days until harvest.

City Cast Las Vegas co-host and culinary historian Sarah Lohman shares more on the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin and her very own recipe for baking the perfect pumpkin pie in a special holiday story for Gastro Obscura.

see more:food

Share article

Hey Las Vegas

Stay connected to City Cast Las Vegas and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Las Vegas

Las Vegas, ExplainedSeptember 16

How Big Can Las Vegas Get?

A plan to upgrade 27 miles of Interstate 15 could kick off a new wave of development between Sloan and Primm.

A sign for Highway 15 in the desert. One arrow on the sign points straight for Barstow, one points to the right for Las Vegas.
Las Vegas, ExplainedSeptember 11

Take This Week's Las Vegas News Trivia Quiz

Ready for a challenge? Take our weekly quiz, based on the news and stories of this past week in Las Vegas.

The sign for the Fiesta Casino and Hotel.
Las Vegas, ExplainedSeptember 11

Victims Honored and Remembered 25 Years After 9/11

Las Vegas joins the rest of the nation in mourning the lives lost during the 9/11 terror attacks, which took place 25 years ago today.

The Statue of Liberty
Keep It LocalSeptember 10

The Vegas Entrepreneur Giving Fan Gear a Makeover

From a Vegas hair agency to major sports licensing deals, discover how Whitney Bansin’s viral gold sequin jackets launched her fashion br...

A couple poses in Raiders jackets.
Keep It LocalSeptember 10

Four Ways to Up Your Sports Game

Discover local businesses that have everything you need to dress the part, find vintage gems, and show love for your favorite team. Dive...

4 Raiders baseball caps sit on a desert ground.
Las Vegas' BestSeptember 2

City Cast Las Vegas Repeats as 'Best Vegas Podcast' in Las Vegas Weekly’s Best of Vegas Awards

For the second year in a row, City Cast Las Vegas was named "Best Vegas Podcast" by Las Vegas Weekly readers.

City Cast staff accept an award.
Las Vegas' BestSeptember 1

Your Guide to Las Vegas in September 2026

Discover the best things to do in Las Vegas, Nevada, in September 2026! From vibrant fall festivals to concerts, plan your perfect autumn...

A tray of various cooked meats and sides of corn and watermelon.
Las Vegas, ExplainedAugust 27

Dolly Parton’s Literary Legacy Unfunded by Nevada

There's new hope for a local chapter of Dolly Parton's Imagination Library, which lost funding when a vital grant expired.

Dolly Parton at the Riviera in Las Vegas, Aug. 2, 1981.