City Cast Las Vegas logo

The Secret to Perfect Pumpkin Pie

Posted on November 26, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Sarah Lohman

Sarah Lohman

A pumpkin grows on the vine

The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin. (Sarah Lohman/City Cast Las Vegas)

If you want to make a really fab pumpkin pie — and have space for a container garden — grow Long Island Cheese Pumpkins! Although this eating squash has an East Coast name, it’s believed to be one of the oldest domesticated squashes and originally hailed from South America. Mojave desert gardeners have noticed that this pumpkin thrives in our hot, arid summers.

It’s famously a low water, high sugar, less-stringy squash that’s perfect for pumpkin pie. All you need is a deep container and seeds from Mojave-based seed sellers Mantis Planting. Make sure to water the roots deeply, but then just let the vines wander and bring a splash of green to your yard 🌱 It takes about 100 days until harvest.

City Cast Las Vegas co-host and culinary historian Sarah Lohman shares more on the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin and her very own recipe for baking the perfect pumpkin pie in a special holiday story for Gastro Obscura.

see more:food

Share article

Hey Las Vegas

Stay connected to City Cast Las Vegas and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Las Vegas

Las Vegas, ExplainedOctober 9

Take This Week's Las Vegas News Trivia Quiz

Ready for a challenge? Take our weekly quiz, based on the news and stories of this past week in Las Vegas.

A close-up of the black-and-white logo on a Metro Police car
Keep It LocalOctober 8

Meet Toni James, the Drag Queen Marrying Couples at Las Vegas Pride

Las Vegas drag superstar Toni James has performed since 1988. Now, as a wedding officiant, he’ll marry couples onstage at the 2026 Las Ve...

Drag performer Toni James sings into a vintage-style microphone onstage, wearing a white halter dress, a pearl necklace, and a flower in his hair.
Keep It LocalOctober 8

Where To Spend Your Pride Dollars Year Round

Support queer Las Vegas beyond Pride with four LGBTQ+-owned and community-centered businesses for books, boba, movement, and nightlife.

Two people stand inside The Analog Dope Store surrounded by shelves of books and vinyl records and a large hand-drawn chalkboard mural.
Keep It LocalOctober 1

Your Guide to Halloween Shopping in Las Vegas

From $75 costume rentals and theatrical makeup to haunted tea and real skulls, these four locally owned Vegas shops have your spooky seas...

Four framed illustrations on aged, parchment-like fabric depicting dark fantasy creatures in a medieval manuscript style, propped against a rough stone wall and surrounded by flickering votive candles — prints from the “Thirteen Ghosts” collection available at Halloween Emporium and Haunted Tea Room.
Keep It LocalOctober 1

A Halloween Costume With a Backstage Pass

Go big this Halloween at On Stage Essentials, where pros behind looks for Lady Gaga and 'Absinthe' help beginners add plumes, sparkle, an...

A dramatic costume from On Stage Essentials in Las Vegas displayed on a mannequin, featuring a blue-and-silver sequined corset bodice with black ribbon detailing, white tulle ruffles at the shoulders, waist and wrists, and a matching tulle neck ruffle.
Las Vegas' BestSeptember 30

Your Guide to Las Vegas in October 2026

Discover what to do in Las Vegas this October! From the Hobie Wave sailing championship to the Las Vegas Book Festival and Gilcrease Orch...

Mulit-colored catamarans on the water.
Las Vegas' BestSeptember 30

The Best Halloween Bars, Attractions, and Festivals in Las Vegas

Haunted houses? Shows? Spooky pop-up bars? We've got all that, plus anything else to make Halloween complete in Las Vegas.

A scary monster looks around a corner in a haunted house.
Las Vegas, ExplainedSeptember 30

Just How Doomed Is the Train to California?

Once a surefire promise for the 2028 Olympics, Brightline West faces skyrocketing $21B costs, stalled federal loans, and a sister-company...

A row of yellow, black and silver trains in a train yard.