City Cast Las Vegas logo

The Secret to Perfect Pumpkin Pie

Posted on November 26, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Sarah Lohman

Sarah Lohman

A pumpkin grows on the vine

The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin. (Sarah Lohman/City Cast Las Vegas)

If you want to make a really fab pumpkin pie — and have space for a container garden — grow Long Island Cheese Pumpkins! Although this eating squash has an East Coast name, it’s believed to be one of the oldest domesticated squashes and originally hailed from South America. Mojave desert gardeners have noticed that this pumpkin thrives in our hot, arid summers.

It’s famously a low water, high sugar, less-stringy squash that’s perfect for pumpkin pie. All you need is a deep container and seeds from Mojave-based seed sellers Mantis Planting. Make sure to water the roots deeply, but then just let the vines wander and bring a splash of green to your yard 🌱 It takes about 100 days until harvest.

City Cast Las Vegas co-host and culinary historian Sarah Lohman shares more on the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin and her very own recipe for baking the perfect pumpkin pie in a special holiday story for Gastro Obscura.

see more:food

Share article

Hey Las Vegas

Stay connected to City Cast Las Vegas and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Las Vegas

Las Vegas HistoryOctober 30

Why Isn’t Nevada Day On Halloween This Year?

Nevada Day and Halloween both fall on Friday this year. There's a reason for that. A few of 'em, actually.

A road sign that says "Welcome to Nevada" on a desert highway.
Keep It LocalOctober 29

4 Boulder City Stops for Food, Books, and Railroad History

Plan a Boulder City day with Fox Smokehouse BBQ, the Nevada State Railroad Museum, Dam Roast House & Browder Bookstore, and Dough Yummy.

Three thick slices of Richard’s zucchini bread at Dough Yummy, served with butter, sliced bananas, strawberries, and syrup on a pale blue plate.
Keep It LocalOctober 29

Explore Boulder City’s New Travel Nevada Adventure Center

Boulder City’s new Adventure Center makes booking a bike ride, asking about a kayaking trip, and planning an exploration of Southern Neva...

 turquoise van outside the Nevada Adventure Center's building in Boulder City, with desert mountains and sunlit clouds behind it.
Las Vegas HistoryOctober 26

The Most Haunted Casinos in Las Vegas

Las Vegas casinos are full of history, stories ... and spirits. Some even have a reputation for being haunted.

The exterior of the El Cortez casino at night.
Las Vegas, ExplainedOctober 23

Take This Week's Las Vegas News Trivia Quiz

Ready for a challenge? Take our weekly quiz, based on the news and stories of this past week in Las Vegas.

A clear jar with a yellow sticky that reads "TIP".
Keep It LocalOctober 22

Bloomscroll These Las Vegas Floral Artists

Need a pick me up? Bloomscroll these four local feeds for showgirl-worthy orchids, a rose piano for John Legend, and zodiac-inspired bouq...

Yellow sunflower arrangements and white pillar candles line a curved black staircase in a white room with framed artwork and a black-and-white checkered floor.
Las Vegas, ExplainedOctober 22

Developers Plan to Build a Lake in Bonnie Springs

A vote is scheduled on a proposed lake in Bonnie Springs as a new luxury home development slowly takes shape.

A building up against desert mountains and a sign that reads "Bonnie Springs Motel Resort"
Keep It LocalOctober 22

Meet Nate Guerrero, a Las Vegas Floral and Event Designer

For Nate Guerrero, a room isn’t alive until it has flowers. The Elev8 Agency founder shares how listening to clients shapes every wedding...

Nate Guerrero wears sunglasses and a gray suit while seated on concrete steps between two arrangements of red, peach, and white flowers under a blue sky.