City Cast Las Vegas logo

Primary Results Analysis: Henderson’s Ice Cream Election

Posted on June 13, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Sarah Lohman

Sarah Lohman

Children eating ice cream cones.

Every vote counts. (wundervisuals/Getty)

To teach children about voting, the city of Henderson held an Ice Cream Election, which we first told you about in February.

Many were shocked when Cookies & Cream edged out Vanilla for the top slot in the presidential preference primary in February. Going into the primary, four flavors were duking it out: Chocolate, Vanilla, Cookies & Cream and Bubblegum. Cookies & Cream won by an incredible margain, 128 votes to Vanilla's 84.

Hilariously, the ballot also had a "None of these Candidates" option, which garnered six votes. The total child voter turnout was 359.

As the top two head to the general in November, you may say that Cookies & Cream is just Vanilla with some chocolate cookie bits — and you would be right. But Vanilla has been America's favorite ice cream for the past 200 years. Textural ice creams have only become popular for the past century — a fraction of sweet treat’s 400-plus year history. If Cookies & Cream wins the election this fall, it would be a huge upset for the status quo. When I reported the early results to ice cream historian Jeri Quinzio, she actually slapped her knee and exclaimed: "After all this time!"

Will the old favorite make a comeback or will this slightly younger, slightly different upstart finally bring about change? I for one will be closely following the election this November as these two flavors square off head to head.

Share article

Hey Las Vegas

Stay connected to City Cast Las Vegas and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Las Vegas

Las Vegas' BestSeptember 29

The Sphere’s Best Moments … So Far

As Metallica debuts a new residency, we look back on three years of the Sphere and our favorite moments so far.

A wall of screens inside the Sphere.
Mayoral MondaysSeptember 28

Mayoral Races to Watch in Southern Nevada

Voters will help choose two new mayors in Southern Nevada. Who are the candidates and what do they stand for?

Poll workers in yellow shirts look over people voting in voting booths set up at a mall.
Las Vegas, ExplainedSeptember 25

Take This Week's Las Vegas News Trivia Quiz

Ready for a challenge? Take our weekly quiz, based on the news and stories of this past week in Las Vegas.

A large excavator digs.
Las Vegas' BestSeptember 24

Celebrate Dolly Parton on 9 to 5 Day

Saturday is Sept. 25 or “9 to 5 Day,” which gives Las Vegas the perfect opportunity to celebrate the legacy of Dolly Parton.

Dolly Parton sings on a stage at Laughlin Event Center in 2016.
Keep It LocalSeptember 24

Meet Water Street’s Movers and Shakers

From Strip pastry chefs to local architects, discover the passionate people building their businesses and lives right here on Henderson's...

Architect Windom Kimsey stands at a bar at Public Works.
Keep It LocalSeptember 24

Your Water Street Micro-Neighborhood Guide

Discover how Henderson’s Water Street got its name from a 1942 wartime pipeline. Explore the historic district, local businesses, and par...

An open and light dining space with white chairs and tables, wood floors and a chandelier.
Keep It LocalSeptember 17

Your Guide to Las Vegas Butcher Shops

Explore Las Vegas' best butcher counters, from whole-animal butchery at Featherblade to Diamond Spur's ranch beef. Find dry-aged ribeye,...

A close up of a cheeseburger in a wrapper, showing the melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and meat.
Keep It LocalSeptember 17

Know Thy Meat: A Buying Guide with Chef Brad Wise

Master the meat counter with 5 expert tips from Brad Wise of Wise Ox. Plus, get a sneak peek at their new Las Vegas location and 2027 Ox...

A glass case showing cuts of meat.